Ma rch 19, 2008

End-Product Regulation of Biotech Is Clear Winner, Says Columnist

Washington, D.C. area food and drug lawyer Mark I. Schwartz’s recently penned a column questioning whether the European Union’s continued use of the "precautionary principle," to "effectively precluded the cultivation or sale of biotech crops or foods anywhere within its borders," or the United State’s end-product regulation of biotech crops and foods has been more successful.

Schwartz wrote that while the U.S. has developed and approved dozens of new biotech crops and foods over the past decade, the EU has been reluctant to approve any such crops or foods. He also noted the commercial success of biotech crops in the U.S. where about 90 percent of the soybeans, close to 80 percent of the cotton and 60 percent of the corn planted are biotech varieties. And close to three-quarters of the processed foods in U.S. supermarkets contain ingredients from biotech plants, he wrote.

According to Schwartz, the integration of biotech foods into the U.S. economy has its scientific origin in the 1986 Coordinated Framework for Regulation of Biotechnology policy statement, which argued that the characteristics of the end-product, rather than the characteristics of the process by which the product was developed, determine the risk level and hence the level of federal regulation.

By the end of 2007, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration had evaluated about 70 biotech-food products and found them all to be as safe as their conventional counterparts. And a large body of independent scientific evidence confirms there is nothing about biotech foods that causes them to be inherently more dangerous than foods made from crops that were not enhanced with biotech.

Schwartz concludes that after 10 years of data, comparing the two regulatory frameworks – the process-oriented or the end-product-oriented, on the basis of production costs, the diversity of new varieties or safety – the clear winner in economic terms is the U.S.’s end-product regulation of biotech crops and foods.

"Views From Beyond the Barron's Staff: Too Much Precaution About Biotech Corn, Mark I. Schwartz, Barron's


Corn Genome Draft Sequence Celebrated by NCGA

The National Corn Growers Association (NCGA) recently congratulated the scientific research community for completing a draft sequence of the corn genome. After three years and $30 million, the National Science Foundation Plant Genome announced the completion of the first part of the massive public-private project. According to the NCGA, this breakthrough, combined with information already available, will contribute to researchers' understanding of plant genetics.

"The completion of a maize draft sequence is the first step in determining the function of all the genes in corn, which, in turn, will allow corn growers to plant corn hybrids that are better able to withstand drought and other stresses and are better suited to market and environmental needs," said NCGA President Ron Litterer. "Consumers will benefit from a more nutritious, abundant and sustainable food supply."

The completed corn genome sequence will help increase breeding efficiencies, streamline delivery of new traits, and will further the recognition and understanding of traits that will enhance corn's position as the ideal crop for food, feed, fuel and industrial uses, according to the NCGA.

"National Corn Growers Association Applauds Scientists for Completing Corn Genome Draft Sequence," The Corn and Soybean Digest

Biotechnology Will Help Farmers Meet Food, Feed and Fuel Demands, Says Expert

Agricultural biotechnology will continue to increase crop yields, helping farmers meet demands for food, feed and fuel, according to Brent Erickson, Biotechnology Industry Organization (BIO) executive vice president, Industrial and Environmental Section. "Over the past 10 years, agricultural biotechnology has helped U.S. farmers increase yields by 30 percent, a rate of yield increase that will be sufficient to meet the goals of the new renewable fuel standard," he continued.

Erikson, speaking at an event titled "Sustainable Development of Advanced Biofuels for the 21st Century," held in conjunction with the Washington International Renewable Energy Conference 2008, said industrial biotechnology has enhanced the efficiency of biofuel production and has made possible the production of advanced biofuels from a broader range of cellulosic feedstocks. "Rapid advances in industrial biotechnology are bringing next-generation biofuels closer to reality," Erikson said.

Erikson noted that while biotechnology will continue to increase biofuel production efficiencies, it will also help significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions. By using biotechnology, "farmers can reduce operating costs, prevent soil erosion, maintain soil fertility and harvest crop residues as raw materials for advanced biofuels through adoption of no-till agriculture. In many cases no-till practices can even result in carbon sequestration," he said.

The recent BIO report, "
Achieving Sustainable Production of Agricultural Biomass for Biorefinery Feedstock," outlines how farmers can produce, harvest and deliver sufficient feedstock to the growing biorefinery industry in an economically and environmentally sustainable way through increased use of no-till agriculture.

"Biotechnology Is Key to Sustainable Production of Biofuels, BIO Says," Business Wire 


Technology Benefits Farmers and the Environment

From corn to soybeans plant technology has transformed agriculture into a science-based business, improving yields and benefiting the environment. The article’s author claims that of the many ag technologies introduced over the past 20 years, the two that have the most impact are the introduction of herbicide-resistant soybeans and corn.

Herbicide-resistance allows farmers to control weeds by spraying herbicide over growing crops without harming them. Better weed control means increased yields and improved income. And when used in conjunction with no- and minimum-tillage practices, it helps reduce environmental impact and erosion.

Hank Choate, a dairy farmer from Liberty Township, Michigan says that "through development of new technology, we are being much better stewards of the soil than farmers even 20 or 25 years ago."

The author also points out that science has also developed crops that repel diseases and pests such as corn rootworm, soybean nematode, alfalfa leaf hopper and wheat scab, reducing the amount of pesticides required.

"High-tech Farming is a Growing Industry," Steven Hepker, Jackson Citizen Patriot (Michigan)


GM Acres Grow as Resistance Wanes and Food Demand Increases

According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Nebraska’s farmers continue to plant more acres of genetically modified (GM) corn and soybean. The percentage of GM corn acres in Nebraska increased from 34 percent in 2000 to 79 percent in 2007; GM soybean acres increased from 72 percent to 96 percent during the same time period. Nationally, GM corn acres increased from 25 percent in 2000 to 73 percent in 2007, and GM soybean acres increased from 54 percent in 2000 to 91 percent in 2007.

The promise of GM crops – higher yields with less water and fertilizer – is difficult to resist, the author notes. Internationally, the number of acres planted with GM crops grew 12 percent last year according to an industry group, as farmers in countries such as Argentina, Brazil, India and China continued to expand use.

Europe continues to hold out against GM crops, even as demand for food climbs globally. The farming lobby group, Copa-Cogeca recently told The Economist magazine that the rising cost of feed could jeopardize Europe's livestock industry and called on the European Commission to lift restrictions on GM feed grains.

The author points out that after years of raising the alarm of the purported dangers of what opponents like to call "Frankenfood," their dire predictions have failed to come true.

"Genetically modified revolution continues," Lincoln Journal Star (Nebraska)



© 2008 Monsanto Company



To receive The Biotechnology Advantage every other week, enter your email address and click the 'Subscribe' button.

The stories presented in The Biotech Advantage are compiled and summarized from various media sources. The expressed views and opinions are from those sources and do not necessarily reflect positions of Monsanto.

© 2008 Monsanto



Subscription
To receive the latest issue of the Biotechnology Advantage every other week, please enter your e-mail address below, then click the "Subscribe" button.

Format:
HTML Text
Email:

Feedback
Please share your thoughts about this newsletter with us. Enter your name, e-mail address, and a message in the spaces below, then click the "send feedback" button.

Name:
Email:
Message: